Collar or Harness for Your Dog: Making the Right Choice

Collar or Harness for Your Dog: Making the Right Choice

should I use a collar or harness for my dog

Choosing between a collar and a harness for your furry friend is an important decision for any dog owner. Both options serve essential functions, but they come with their own set of advantages and considerations. To make an informed choice, it's essential to understand the pros and cons of each and consider your dog's specific needs and behaviour. In this blog post, we'll explore the benefits and drawbacks of collars and harnesses to help you decide which is the best fit for your canine companion.

The Collar


  1. ID Tags: Collars are the go-to choice for displaying your dog's identification tags, including their name, your contact information, which is required by law. This makes it easier for anyone who finds your dog to return them safely.

  2. Training and Obedience: Training with a collar is often more straightforward for basic commands like sit, stay, and heel. The gentle pressure around the neck helps dogs understand and respond to your commands.

  3. Everyday Wear: Collars are lightweight and easy to put on and take off, making them a practical choice for everyday use. 


  1. Health Concerns: Collars can pose a risk of injury, especially in dogs that pull on the leash. Prolonged pulling can cause tracheal damage and even lead to respiratory problems in some breeds.

  2. Choking Hazard: If not properly fitted, a collar can slip off or tighten too much, posing a choking hazard, especially for small or wriggly dogs.

The Harness


  1. Reduced Strain: Harnesses distribute the force of pulling across your dog's chest and shoulders rather than their neck. This can reduce the risk of injury and discomfort, making them an excellent choice for dogs that tend to pull on the leash.

  2. Safety: For smaller breeds or dogs with respiratory issues, harnesses can be a safer option as they eliminate the risk of choking or tracheal damage.

  3. Control: If your dog is strong and energetic, a harness gives you more control during walks and discourages them from pulling.


  1. Training Differences: Some dogs may not respond as well to commands with a harness on, as the pressure isn't directly on the neck.

  2. Putting It On: Harnesses can be a bit more cumbersome to put on, especially for wriggly or impatient dogs.

In conclusion, the choice between a collar and a harness ultimately depends on your dog's individual needs and behaviours, as well as your preferences as an owner. Here are some considerations to help you decide:

  1. Dog's Size: Smaller dogs and breeds prone to respiratory issues are better off with harnesses, while collars may be suitable for larger and well-trained dogs.

  2. Leash Training: If you're actively working on leash training, a harness may provide better control over pulling.

  3. Everyday Use: For everyday wear and displaying ID tags, a collar is a convenient choice.

  4. Combination: Some owners opt for a combination of both, using a collar for ID purposes and a harness for walks.

Remember that whatever you choose, it's crucial to ensure a proper fit and regularly check for wear and tear. Consult with your veterinarian or a professional dog trainer for personalised recommendations based on your dog's specific needs. Your furry friend's safety and comfort should always be the top priority.

At Pup Chic Boutique we have a wide variety of collars and harnesses to suit all sizes of dogs. Shop now to find the perfect one for your furry friend.

Back to blog